Last night's Question Time

In-depth debate on all topical issues
User avatar
Roy Twing
Registered user
Posts: 5403
Joined: Sun Oct 07, 2007 4:20 pm
Location: 51 23 46 N 0 11 56 W

Re: Last night's Question Time

Post by Roy Twing »

Royal24s wrote:I doubt that many normal people know who they are actually. I gather from these posts that they're some kind of right wing nutters, but you'd have to be very invested in impractical fringe politics to be familiar with groups like that.
They sound just as bonkers as socialists to me actually .
From the other end of the spectrum ideologically, but no more extreme than the likes of UAF, but the supporters of that outfit, which includes prominent MPs & 'celebs', and no doubt also include some bbc researchers, do not get the same condemnation.
E & OE

User avatar
warmleatherette
Registered user
Posts: 1843
Joined: Mon Mar 26, 2007 4:23 pm

Re: Last night's Question Time

Post by warmleatherette »

Ralph wrote:
Royal24s wrote:I doubt that many normal people know who they are actually. I gather from these posts that they're some kind of right wing nutters, but you'd have to be very invested in impractical fringe politics to be familiar with groups like that.
They sound just as bonkers as socialists to me actually .
https://www.google.co.uk/amp/www.indepe ... ent=safari

Or read the news. I'd heard of Britain First & I'm not a political insider. She's a producer on Question Time. Knowing who's who in the world of politics is her job.
It's not a matter of knowing who they are, it's very easy to like a post a friend has liked without looking at where it originated, that's how they work, make a meme stating the bloody obvious and collect those likes from the unsuspecting, I often comment with a lol on ultra left friends who fall for it time and time again.
Brilliantly Honest

User avatar
Ralph
Forum Admin
Posts: 5506
Joined: Sat Aug 25, 2012 1:42 pm

Re: Last night's Question Time

Post by Ralph »

warmleatherette wrote:
Ralph wrote:
Royal24s wrote:I doubt that many normal people know who they are actually. I gather from these posts that they're some kind of right wing nutters, but you'd have to be very invested in impractical fringe politics to be familiar with groups like that.
They sound just as bonkers as socialists to me actually .
https://www.google.co.uk/amp/www.indepe ... ent=safari

Or read the news. I'd heard of Britain First & I'm not a political insider. She's a producer on Question Time. Knowing who's who in the world of politics is her job.
It's not a matter of knowing who they are, it's very easy to like a post a friend has liked without looking at where it originated, that's how they work, make a meme stating the bloody obvious and collect those likes from the unsuspecting, I often comment with a lol on ultra left friends who fall for it time and time again.
Question Time said she didn't understand 'the wider context' of Britain First & that's why she shared the post.

She also used her facebook account to encourage EDL members to join the Question Time audience.

https://www.google.co.uk/amp/www.telegr ... ent=safari

User avatar
Ralph
Forum Admin
Posts: 5506
Joined: Sat Aug 25, 2012 1:42 pm

Re: Last night's Question Time

Post by Ralph »

Roy Twing wrote:
Royal24s wrote:I doubt that many normal people know who they are actually. I gather from these posts that they're some kind of right wing nutters, but you'd have to be very invested in impractical fringe politics to be familiar with groups like that.
They sound just as bonkers as socialists to me actually .
From the other end of the spectrum ideologically, but no more extreme than the likes of UAF, but the supporters of that outfit, which includes prominent MPs & 'celebs', and no doubt also include some bbc researchers, do not get the same condemnation.
Give me an example of a someone working for a BBC political programme while (accidentally) promoting violent left wing groups & I'll condemn it. Do you condemn this? Pretty shoddy isn't it?

User avatar
warmleatherette
Registered user
Posts: 1843
Joined: Mon Mar 26, 2007 4:23 pm

Re: Last night's Question Time

Post by warmleatherette »

Ralph wrote:
warmleatherette wrote:
Ralph wrote:
Royal24s wrote:I doubt that many normal people know who they are actually. I gather from these posts that they're some kind of right wing nutters, but you'd have to be very invested in impractical fringe politics to be familiar with groups like that.
They sound just as bonkers as socialists to me actually .
https://www.google.co.uk/amp/www.indepe ... ent=safari

Or read the news. I'd heard of Britain First & I'm not a political insider. She's a producer on Question Time. Knowing who's who in the world of politics is her job.
It's not a matter of knowing who they are, it's very easy to like a post a friend has liked without looking at where it originated, that's how they work, make a meme stating the bloody obvious and collect those likes from the unsuspecting, I often comment with a lol on ultra left friends who fall for it time and time again.
Question Time said she didn't understand 'the wider context' of Britain First & that's why she shared the post.

She also used her facebook account to encourage EDL members to join the Question Time audience.

https://www.google.co.uk/amp/www.telegr ... ent=safari
Mmm that's what I would have said if I was stupid enough to share one of their posts, I don't see the problem with the EDL thing, I would have watched it and I suspect you would have as well :-)
Brilliantly Honest

User avatar
Roy Twing
Registered user
Posts: 5403
Joined: Sun Oct 07, 2007 4:20 pm
Location: 51 23 46 N 0 11 56 W

Re: Last night's Question Time

Post by Roy Twing »

Ralph wrote:
Roy Twing wrote:
Royal24s wrote:I doubt that many normal people know who they are actually. I gather from these posts that they're some kind of right wing nutters, but you'd have to be very invested in impractical fringe politics to be familiar with groups like that.
They sound just as bonkers as socialists to me actually .
From the other end of the spectrum ideologically, but no more extreme than the likes of UAF, but the supporters of that outfit, which includes prominent MPs & 'celebs', and no doubt also include some bbc researchers, do not get the same condemnation.
Give me an example of a someone working for a BBC political programme while (accidentally) promoting violent left wing groups & I'll condemn it. Do you condemn this? Pretty shoddy isn't it?

I can give you a list of prominent MPs & 'celebs' actively promoting a violent left wing group, - will you condemn it?
E & OE

User avatar
warmleatherette
Registered user
Posts: 1843
Joined: Mon Mar 26, 2007 4:23 pm

Re: Last night's Question Time

Post by warmleatherette »

Ralph wrote:
Roy Twing wrote:
Royal24s wrote:I doubt that many normal people know who they are actually. I gather from these posts that they're some kind of right wing nutters, but you'd have to be very invested in impractical fringe politics to be familiar with groups like that.
They sound just as bonkers as socialists to me actually .
From the other end of the spectrum ideologically, but no more extreme than the likes of UAF, but the supporters of that outfit, which includes prominent MPs & 'celebs', and no doubt also include some bbc researchers, do not get the same condemnation.
Give me an example of a someone working for a BBC political programme while (accidentally) promoting violent left wing groups & I'll condemn it. Do you condemn this? Pretty shoddy isn't it?
Is getting suckered into sharing a Britain first poppy post classed as "promoting right wing groups" or is it just being gullible?
Brilliantly Honest

User avatar
Ralph
Forum Admin
Posts: 5506
Joined: Sat Aug 25, 2012 1:42 pm

Re: Last night's Question Time

Post by Ralph »

warmleatherette wrote:
Ralph wrote:
warmleatherette wrote:
Ralph wrote:
Royal24s wrote:I doubt that many normal people know who they are actually. I gather from these posts that they're some kind of right wing nutters, but you'd have to be very invested in impractical fringe politics to be familiar with groups like that.
They sound just as bonkers as socialists to me actually .
https://www.google.co.uk/amp/www.indepe ... ent=safari

Or read the news. I'd heard of Britain First & I'm not a political insider. She's a producer on Question Time. Knowing who's who in the world of politics is her job.
It's not a matter of knowing who they are, it's very easy to like a post a friend has liked without looking at where it originated, that's how they work, make a meme stating the bloody obvious and collect those likes from the unsuspecting, I often comment with a lol on ultra left friends who fall for it time and time again.
Question Time said she didn't understand 'the wider context' of Britain First & that's why she shared the post.

She also used her facebook account to encourage EDL members to join the Question Time audience.

https://www.google.co.uk/amp/www.telegr ... ent=safari
Mmm that's what I would have said if I was stupid enough to share one of their posts, I don't see the problem with the EDL thing, I would have watched it and I suspect you would have as well :-)
From the safety of my living room. High risk it'd kick off isn't there. If Question Time want to outflank The Jeremy Kyle Show this is the way to do it. :)

User avatar
Ralph
Forum Admin
Posts: 5506
Joined: Sat Aug 25, 2012 1:42 pm

Re: Last night's Question Time

Post by Ralph »

warmleatherette wrote:
Ralph wrote:
Roy Twing wrote:
Royal24s wrote:I doubt that many normal people know who they are actually. I gather from these posts that they're some kind of right wing nutters, but you'd have to be very invested in impractical fringe politics to be familiar with groups like that.
They sound just as bonkers as socialists to me actually .
From the other end of the spectrum ideologically, but no more extreme than the likes of UAF, but the supporters of that outfit, which includes prominent MPs & 'celebs', and no doubt also include some bbc researchers, do not get the same condemnation.
Give me an example of a someone working for a BBC political programme while (accidentally) promoting violent left wing groups & I'll condemn it. Do you condemn this? Pretty shoddy isn't it?
Is getting suckered into sharing a Britain first poppy post classed as "promoting right wing groups" or is it just being gullible?
She shared more than one Britain First meme & invited EDL members to join a Question Time audience.

The most generous explanation is that she was promoting them unwittingly, isn't it?

User avatar
Ralph
Forum Admin
Posts: 5506
Joined: Sat Aug 25, 2012 1:42 pm

Re: Last night's Question Time

Post by Ralph »

Roy Twing wrote:
Ralph wrote:
Roy Twing wrote:
Royal24s wrote:I doubt that many normal people know who they are actually. I gather from these posts that they're some kind of right wing nutters, but you'd have to be very invested in impractical fringe politics to be familiar with groups like that.
They sound just as bonkers as socialists to me actually .
From the other end of the spectrum ideologically, but no more extreme than the likes of UAF, but the supporters of that outfit, which includes prominent MPs & 'celebs', and no doubt also include some bbc researchers, do not get the same condemnation.
Give me an example of a someone working for a BBC political programme while (accidentally) promoting violent left wing groups & I'll condemn it. Do you condemn this? Pretty shoddy isn't it?

I can give you a list of prominent MPs & 'celebs' actively promoting a violent left wing group, - will you condemn it?
Can't help noticing you're shifting the ground & not answering my question Roy.

I don't think anyone should promote groups who use violence as a tactic. So if that's what they're doing consider it condemned.

What do you think about this BBC producer. Bit odd isn't it?

User avatar
Roy Twing
Registered user
Posts: 5403
Joined: Sun Oct 07, 2007 4:20 pm
Location: 51 23 46 N 0 11 56 W

Re: Last night's Question Time

Post by Roy Twing »

Ralph wrote:
Roy Twing wrote:
Ralph wrote:
Roy Twing wrote:
Royal24s wrote:I doubt that many normal people know who they are actually. I gather from these posts that they're some kind of right wing nutters, but you'd have to be very invested in impractical fringe politics to be familiar with groups like that.
They sound just as bonkers as socialists to me actually .
From the other end of the spectrum ideologically, but no more extreme than the likes of UAF, but the supporters of that outfit, which includes prominent MPs & 'celebs', and no doubt also include some bbc researchers, do not get the same condemnation.
Give me an example of a someone working for a BBC political programme while (accidentally) promoting violent left wing groups & I'll condemn it. Do you condemn this? Pretty shoddy isn't it?

I can give you a list of prominent MPs & 'celebs' actively promoting a violent left wing group, - will you condemn it?
Can't help noticing you're shifting the ground & not answering my question Roy.

I don't think anyone should promote groups who use violence as a tactic. So if that's what they're doing consider it condemned.

What do you think about this BBC producer. Bit odd isn't it?
IF the bbc employee is promoting an extremist group he or she should be dealt with accordingly. It goes without saying.
My argument is against the usual dual standards, - I maintain that britain first is no more extrem than the UAF, yet the latter is supported by many mainstream 'names', and they are not attacked for their support.
E & OE

User avatar
warmleatherette
Registered user
Posts: 1843
Joined: Mon Mar 26, 2007 4:23 pm

Re: Last night's Question Time

Post by warmleatherette »

Ralph wrote:
warmleatherette wrote:
Ralph wrote:
Roy Twing wrote:
Royal24s wrote:I doubt that many normal people know who they are actually. I gather from these posts that they're some kind of right wing nutters, but you'd have to be very invested in impractical fringe politics to be familiar with groups like that.
They sound just as bonkers as socialists to me actually .
From the other end of the spectrum ideologically, but no more extreme than the likes of UAF, but the supporters of that outfit, which includes prominent MPs & 'celebs', and no doubt also include some bbc researchers, do not get the same condemnation.
Give me an example of a someone working for a BBC political programme while (accidentally) promoting violent left wing groups & I'll condemn it. Do you condemn this? Pretty shoddy isn't it?
Is getting suckered into sharing a Britain first poppy post classed as "promoting right wing groups" or is it just being gullible?
She shared more than one Britain First meme & invited EDL members to join a Question Time audience.

The most generous explanation is that she was promoting them unwittingly, isn't it?
The most generous explanation is she's a typical just out of a media degree graduate that has connected parents who got her the job trying to be "edgy" and making a name for herself, but I can't be bothered to check :-)
Brilliantly Honest

User avatar
Ralph
Forum Admin
Posts: 5506
Joined: Sat Aug 25, 2012 1:42 pm

Re: Last night's Question Time

Post by Ralph »

Roy Twing wrote:
Ralph wrote:
Roy Twing wrote:
Ralph wrote:
Roy Twing wrote:
Royal24s wrote:I doubt that many normal people know who they are actually. I gather from these posts that they're some kind of right wing nutters, but you'd have to be very invested in impractical fringe politics to be familiar with groups like that.
They sound just as bonkers as socialists to me actually .
From the other end of the spectrum ideologically, but no more extreme than the likes of UAF, but the supporters of that outfit, which includes prominent MPs & 'celebs', and no doubt also include some bbc researchers, do not get the same condemnation.
Give me an example of a someone working for a BBC political programme while (accidentally) promoting violent left wing groups & I'll condemn it. Do you condemn this? Pretty shoddy isn't it?

I can give you a list of prominent MPs & 'celebs' actively promoting a violent left wing group, - will you condemn it?
Can't help noticing you're shifting the ground & not answering my question Roy.

I don't think anyone should promote groups who use violence as a tactic. So if that's what they're doing consider it condemned.

What do you think about this BBC producer. Bit odd isn't it?
IF the bbc employee is promoting an extremist group he or she should be dealt with accordingly. It goes without saying.
My argument is against the usual dual standards, - I maintain that britain first is no more extrem than the UAF, yet the latter is supported by many mainstream 'names', and they are not attacked for their support.
She's not a celeb or an MP she's a BBC producer on Question Time. She should be studiously impartial.

She shouldn't be backing/promoting/endorsing any political party, let alone violent ones that could be proscribed as terrorist organisations.

She also shouldn't be sending Facebook invitations to far right groups to join the Question Time audience.

It's a slightly worrying pattern of behaviour for someone who's supposed to be completely impartial? The dismissive response from the BBC is also worrying.

User avatar
warmleatherette
Registered user
Posts: 1843
Joined: Mon Mar 26, 2007 4:23 pm

Re: Last night's Question Time

Post by warmleatherette »

I take it back, she's an old girl, hardcore racist :-)
Brilliantly Honest

User avatar
Kowalski
Registered user
Posts: 4201
Joined: Tue Dec 08, 2009 11:57 pm

Re: Last night's Question Time

Post by Kowalski »

Which political party is she backing/promoting/endorsing?

User avatar
Ralph
Forum Admin
Posts: 5506
Joined: Sat Aug 25, 2012 1:42 pm

Re: Last night's Question Time

Post by Ralph »

Kowalski wrote:Which political party is she backing/promoting/endorsing?
Britain First. She says she shared the Britain First memes not knowing who they were. I'm not a mind reader so I'll take her word for that.

User avatar
warmleatherette
Registered user
Posts: 1843
Joined: Mon Mar 26, 2007 4:23 pm

Re: Last night's Question Time

Post by warmleatherette »

Kowalski wrote:Which political party is she backing/promoting/endorsing?
No idea, if you start judging people on what they've shared on their facebook page we're all up shit creek :-)
Brilliantly Honest

User avatar
warmleatherette
Registered user
Posts: 1843
Joined: Mon Mar 26, 2007 4:23 pm

Re: Last night's Question Time

Post by warmleatherette »

Ralph wrote:
Kowalski wrote:Which political party is she backing/promoting/endorsing?
Britain First. She says she shared the Britain First memes not knowing who they were. I'm not a mind reader so I'll take her word for that.
To be fair she shared the proud to wear a poppy and we support our troops posts, hardly extremist and I doubt many would
not agree with the sentiment which is why they post them.
Brilliantly Honest

User avatar
Ralph
Forum Admin
Posts: 5506
Joined: Sat Aug 25, 2012 1:42 pm

Re: Last night's Question Time

Post by Ralph »

Britain First everybody...

http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/ho ... 21201.html

Using Lee Rigby to promote themselves after they've been asked to stop by his family.

Why nobody should share their Facebook memes, let alone staff on BBC political programmes.

User avatar
Ralph
Forum Admin
Posts: 5506
Joined: Sat Aug 25, 2012 1:42 pm

Re: Last night's Question Time

Post by Ralph »

warmleatherette wrote:
Ralph wrote:
Kowalski wrote:Which political party is she backing/promoting/endorsing?
Britain First. She says she shared the Britain First memes not knowing who they were. I'm not a mind reader so I'll take her word for that.
To be fair she shared the proud to wear a poppy and we support our troops posts, hardly extremist and I doubt many would
not agree with the sentiment which is why they post them.
It's Britain First that's the problem not the poppy or expressing support for our troops.

If she'd posted something from the British Legion there wouldn't be a problem.

User avatar
Kowalski
Registered user
Posts: 4201
Joined: Tue Dec 08, 2009 11:57 pm

Re: Last night's Question Time

Post by Kowalski »

Ralph wrote:
Kowalski wrote:Which political party is she backing/promoting/endorsing?
Britain First. She says she shared the Britain First memes not knowing who they were. I'm not a mind reader so I'll take her word for that.
But they're not a political party. More of a right wing group.

User avatar
Ralph
Forum Admin
Posts: 5506
Joined: Sat Aug 25, 2012 1:42 pm

Re: Last night's Question Time

Post by Ralph »

Kowalski wrote:
Ralph wrote:
Kowalski wrote:Which political party is she backing/promoting/endorsing?
Britain First. She says she shared the Britain First memes not knowing who they were. I'm not a mind reader so I'll take her word for that.
But they're not a political party. More of a right wing group.
That's a distinction without a difference isn't it. And they stand candidates in elections so...

The British Legion have asked Britain First to stop using the poppy to promote themselves, yet they still do it.

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/history/worl ... -them.html

User avatar
Roy Twing
Registered user
Posts: 5403
Joined: Sun Oct 07, 2007 4:20 pm
Location: 51 23 46 N 0 11 56 W

Re: Last night's Question Time

Post by Roy Twing »

Ralph wrote:
Kowalski wrote:
Ralph wrote:
Kowalski wrote:Which political party is she backing/promoting/endorsing?
Britain First. She says she shared the Britain First memes not knowing who they were. I'm not a mind reader so I'll take her word for that.
But they're not a political party. More of a right wing group.
That's a distinction without a difference isn't it. And they stand candidates in elections so...

The British Legion have asked Britain First to stop using the poppy to promote themselves, yet they still do it.

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/history/worl ... -them.html

Don't you think that most if not all bbc employees have political views ralph?

Why are you like a dog with a bone on this barely newsworthy story?
E & OE

User avatar
Kowalski
Registered user
Posts: 4201
Joined: Tue Dec 08, 2009 11:57 pm

Re: Last night's Question Time

Post by Kowalski »

Ralph wrote:
Kowalski wrote:
Ralph wrote:
Kowalski wrote:Which political party is she backing/promoting/endorsing?
Britain First. She says she shared the Britain First memes not knowing who they were. I'm not a mind reader so I'll take her word for that.
But they're not a political party. More of a right wing group.
That's a distinction without a difference isn't it. And they stand candidates in elections so...

The British Legion have asked Britain First to stop using the poppy to promote themselves, yet they still do it.

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/history/worl ... -them.html
My apologies, I didn't realise they'd stood in elections.

User avatar
Roy Twing
Registered user
Posts: 5403
Joined: Sun Oct 07, 2007 4:20 pm
Location: 51 23 46 N 0 11 56 W

Re: Last night's Question Time

Post by Roy Twing »

Nige is on QT tonight so always worth a watch.
E & OE

Post Reply